Captain Flint- Toby Stephens- Flint has the most intelligence paired with determination. He thinks things through and usually strives for what he thinks is right while still wrestling with himself about the things he knows are wrong.
John Silver- Luke Arnold- He is the most smooth talker as far as the men go. He is constantly staying alive just based on his tongue.
Captain Charles Vane- Zach McGowan- Impulsive and Strong. He goes into everything guns a-blazing and consequences be damned.
Billy Bones- Tom Hopper- He was wronged as a child and had the moral integrity to stay away from home when he took care of the people who wronged him. Plus, he's not a bad looking guy.